Comparing Your Contracting Routes: Guide to Contractor Employment Choices

I f you’re considering contracting in the UK, one of the first—and most important—decisions you’ll make is how to structure your working arrangements. Each option carries different tax, administrative and liability implications. To help you choose the path that best suits your career goals and lifestyle, ASA Pay Solutions has put together this clear, straightforward comparison of the four main contractor employment models.

Working Through an Umbrella Company

An umbrella company acts as your employer for PAYE purposes. You submit your timesheets and expenses to the umbrella, they invoice the agency or end client, deduct Income Tax and National Insurance Contributions (NICs), take a small margin, then pay you your net salary on their payroll.

Pros

Minimal administration: No need to set up a company or file annual accounts.
Employee rights: You get statutory benefits such as holiday pay and statutory sick pay.
IR35 insulation: The umbrella handles any IR35 determinations on your behalf.

Cons

Margin fees: You pay a weekly or monthly fee to the umbrella provider.
Expense limits: Only certain business expenses are claimable, in line with HMRC guidelines.

How ASA Pay Solutions Helps

Due-Diligence Guidance: We supply checklists to verify your umbrella partner’s compliance with HMRC.
Contract Reviews: Our experts draft and review your engagement letters to ensure you’re covered.
Expense Claim Templates: Clear, manual forms to track and validate allowable costs.
Dedicated Support: Call or email our team with any umbrella-related queries—no portals required.

Operating via a Personal Limited Company

Setting up your own limited company gives you the status of both shareholder and director. You pay yourself via a mix of salary and dividends, which can be more tax-efficient than straight PAYE.

Pros

Tax efficiency: Potentially lower overall tax from dividend treatment.
Liability protection: Your personal assets are generally protected if the company incurs debts.
Expense claims: Broader range of allowable business expenses.

Cons

Increased admin: Annual accounts, Corporation Tax returns and VAT (if applicable).

Regulatory compliance: Maintaining statutory records, filing deadlines and IR35 status checks.

How ASA Pay Solutions Helps

Formation Advice: Step-by-step checklists for Companies House registration.
IR35 Status Support: Telephone guidance on conducting robust status assessments.
Accounting Partner Referrals: We can introduce you to trusted contractor accountants for bookkeeping and tax filings.

Agency PAYE Engagement

Some recruitment agencies offer PAYE terms directly. You’re paid through the agency’s payroll as a casual worker or temporary staff, without umbrella involvement.

Pros

No company setup: Simple PAYE deductions handled entirely by the agency.
Suitable for “gig” work: Ideal for short-term or irregular assignments.

Cons

Fewer employee benefits: Generally limited statutory rights and no umbrella holiday pay.
Lower take-home: You may miss out on expense reimbursements that umbrellas or limited companies allow.

How ASA Pay Solutions Helps

Contract Evaluation: We help you spot gaps in agency PAYE contracts—such as missing holiday pay or unclear tax codes.
Assignment Planning: Advice on when PAYE makes sense versus switching to an umbrella or limited company.
Clarification Support: Email or call our team to discuss any unexpected deductions or benefit shortfalls.

Trading as a Sole Trader

As a sole trader, you operate under your own name (or trading name), report income via Self Assessment, and bear full responsibility for debts and liabilities.

Pros

Easy setup: Register as self-employed with HMRC; minimal ongoing admin.
Full expense claims: Wide scope to deduct legitimate business costs.

Cons

Unlimited liability: Your personal assets are at risk if the business incurs debts.
Less tax planning: No dividend/salary split benefits; all profits are liable to Income Tax and NICs.
Self-managed compliance: Annual tax returns and Class 2/4 NICs to calculate.

How ASA Pay Solutions Helps

Self-Assessment Guidance: Structured checklists to prepare and file your tax return on time.
Expense Record-Keeping: Manual templates to ensure you capture every allowable cost.
Liability Awareness: Expert advice on personal risk management and when to consider incorporation.

Comparing Your Contracting Routes: Guide to Contractor Employment Choices

Need more information?

Related posts